ANSWERS ยท 106 QUESTIONS

Every question, answered short.

The full reasoning is one click away.

The questions Muslims actually ask about crypto, trading, staking, zakat and screening. Answered by the ShariaQuant team, each one linked to the article carrying the full argument. Nothing here is written by anonymous strangers.

New to all this?

These answers assume you already know the words. The free path builds them up from zero in 21 short lessons.

Start learning โ†’

Crypto basics

There is no single answer for all of crypto, because crypto is not one thing. Each coin is a different project with different tokenomics, and the ruling follows the project. Bitcoin and Ethereum pass our screen, while a lending protocol that pays interest does not, so the honest answer is that you screen the asset rather than the asset class.

Every coin we screened โ†’

Yes on our screen. Bitcoin has no interest mechanism, no issuer who owes you anything, and no gambling built into it, so the three usual prohibitions do not attach. The scholarly disagreement about Bitcoin is almost never about riba, it is about whether a digital asset counts as wealth at all.

Bitcoin's place in Islamic finance โ†’

This is the question underneath every other crypto ruling. Mufti Taqi Usmani ruled crypto impermissible mainly on the grounds that it is not mal, since it has no physical existence and no intrinsic use. The counter position, adopted in Malaysia and elsewhere, is that mal is established by what a society treats as valuable property, and crypto now clears that bar.

Is crypto mal? โ†’

Not by itself, but plenty of what people do with it is. Maysir is about the structure of the contract, not how nervous the trade makes you feel. If your gain requires someone else to lose, and the whole thing is decided by an event you have no stake in, that is a wager, and buying and holding an asset you own is not.

Maysir: investing or gambling โ†’

Riba is a guaranteed increase on a loan of money, and crypto puts it in at least nine places that do not use the word interest. Lending products, borrow markets, funding rates on perpetuals, and most things labelled Earn are the common ones. The tell is simple, if you were promised a return for parting with your coins and getting them back later, you are looking at a loan with an increase.

Riba in plain language โ†’

Gharar is excessive uncertainty about what you are actually buying or what you will actually get. Across the assets we have screened it disqualifies more projects than riba does, usually because the tokenomics are undisclosed, the supply can be changed at will, or the thing the token entitles you to was never defined.

Gharar explained โ†’

Maysir is gambling, and the fiqh definition is precise. You need a zero sum transfer that depends on an uncertain event, where each side can only win what the other loses, and neither side is producing anything. Prediction markets and binary options hit that definition even when they market themselves as information tools.

Maysir: investing or gambling โ†’

One failure is enough. The coin fails if its core business is prohibited, such as lending at interest or running a casino, if its tokenomics contain a guaranteed return that functions as riba, or if what you are buying is too undefined to be a valid sale. Most rejected projects fail on tokenomics rather than on the headline business.

Every haram coin and what breaks it โ†’

Trading rulings

No, and not for one reason. You never take ownership of the asset, both sides of the exchange are deferred when fiqh requires at least one to be immediate, the funding rate on perpetuals is riba, and the position is zero sum so someone has to lose for you to win. Any one of those would be enough on its own.

The four things that break it โ†’

No. Margin is a loan, you pay interest on it by the hour, and that is riba in its clearest form. Even the versions advertised as interest free fail, because the lender still keeps the right to liquidate your position on their terms, which is not a loan any Islamic contract recognises.

The loan nobody calls a loan โ†’

No, because leverage is borrowed money and in every mainstream venue it carries a financing cost. Even at 2x you are trading with funds you do not own, on terms set by a lender who can close you out. Spot only means the amount you can lose is the amount you actually put in.

Spot-only risk rules โ†’

It can be, and holding period is not what decides it. Three conditions do the work, you must genuinely own the asset, settlement must be immediate rather than deferred, and there must be no borrowed money involved. Buying and selling spot Bitcoin twice in one afternoon breaks none of those.

Ownership, settlement, speed โ†’

Yes, provided you are holding spot positions in screened assets with no borrowed funds. Swing trading just means holding for days or weeks instead of minutes, and the length of the hold was never the deciding factor. Ownership, settlement and no debt are what you check.

Investing or trading, which one โ†’

On a spot venue with no leverage, the contract itself is valid, because you are buying and selling assets you own with immediate settlement. The practical problem is different, scalping loses money for most people who attempt it, and fee drag turns a break even strategy into a losing one. Permissible is not the same as wise.

Ownership, settlement, speed โ†’

Islamic law has handled this for centuries under wakala, the law of agency. An agent acts within the authority you granted, and you carry responsibility for what you authorised. So the agent is permissible if the trades it is allowed to make are permissible, and giving a bot open ended permission to trade anything is where people get into trouble.

Who answers for the bot โ†’

Only if the trader you copy is doing halal things, and most of the leaderboard is not. Copy trading executes their decisions in your account, so if they open a leveraged perpetual, you opened a leveraged perpetual. You inherit the ruling along with the position.

The conditions that decide it โ†’

Exchanging one currency for another is permissible when both sides settle on the spot, which is why the bureau de change at the airport is fine. Retail forex is a different product, built on leverage, overnight financing and contracts that never deliver the currency. That version fails.

Swap-free is not halal โ†’

No. An option sells you a right rather than an asset, and fiqh does not recognise a bare right as something that can be bought and sold. Add the deferred settlement and the zero sum payoff and it fails on several counts at once.

The four things that break it โ†’

Earning and yield

Native proof of stake staking is halal, and we say so plainly. You keep ownership of your coins, you carry real risk through slashing, and the reward varies with the work performed, so it is a fee for a service rather than a loan with an increase. Four other products borrow the word staking and pay you interest instead.

The four products that are not โ†’

The staking underneath is fine, and the receipt token is where the questions start. You are handed a tradeable claim on a staked position, and the ruling depends on whether that claim is a genuine ownership share or a debt instrument dressed as one. Read the specific protocol before assuming it inherits the verdict on native staking.

The four products that are not โ†’

Binance Earn is not one product, it is roughly a dozen, and most of them pay you interest. Flexible Savings and the fixed term products are lending, so they fail. On chain staking through the same menu is a different contract and can pass, which is why the answer has to be product by product.

What is Binance Earn, and is it halal? โ†’

Supplying two assets you own to a pool and taking a share of the trading fees is closer to a partnership than a loan, and the fee income itself is earned for a service. The problems are impermissible loss, which is a real risk you are accepting, and the fact that many pools pair a clean asset with a coin that fails screening.

Gharar explained โ†’

An airdrop is a gift, hibah, and receiving a gift is permissible. The catch is what you were given, because a free token from a lending protocol is still a stake in a lending protocol. Screen the project before you claim, and screen it again before you sell.

Screened airdrops โ†’

Yes for a clean network. Mining is work, you spend real electricity and real hardware to secure a network and you are paid for the output, which is a recognised form of earning. The ruling follows the network you are mining, so mining a coin that fails our screen does not become permissible because you mined it yourself.

Our screening method โ†’

Most cloud mining contracts fail, and the reason is gharar rather than riba. You are paying today for an undefined amount of future output from equipment you cannot inspect, operated by a company with no obligation to show you it exists. When the thing being sold cannot be identified, the sale is not valid.

Gharar explained โ†’

Paying today for a token that does not exist yet is a sale of something absent, and Islamic law has a specific framework for that. It turns on three questions, whether the thing is precisely defined, whether the delivery date is fixed, and whether the price is paid in full up front. Most presales fail the first two.

Buying what does not exist โ†’

Being paid for playing is permissible in principle, since it is earning for effort. Two things commonly break it, an entry fee that you only recover by beating other players, which makes it a wager, and game assets sold as speculative investments with no defined utility. Check whether you had to pay to enter before you could earn.

Maysir: investing or gambling โ†’

Cashback on a debit style card that spends your own balance is a discount on your purchase, and discounts are fine. Cashback on a credit card is the harder case, because a benefit attached to a loan is exactly the shape riba takes, and many scholars avoid it for that reason.

Riba in plain language โ†’

Coins and tokens

Holding it to move between trades is where most people use it, and the issues to weigh are the freeze function and what sits behind the reserves. Tether's reserves include interest bearing instruments, which is a separate concern from whether you personally earn interest. We rank each stablecoin individually rather than treating them as one group.

Every stablecoin ranked by Shariah compliance โ†’

Ethereum passes as a network and as an asset. Gas fees pay for computation, staking pays for validation work, and neither is a loan with an increase. What runs on top of Ethereum is a separate question, because the network being clean does not clean the lending protocols deployed on it.

Layer 1 blockchains ranked โ†’

Not automatically, and this surprises people. A meme coin with fixed supply, no team allocation and no promised return contains no riba and no lending, so there is nothing in the contract to prohibit. Where they fail is usually gharar, an undisclosed supply or a team wallet that can dump on you, and the way most people buy them is closer to a wager than a purchase.

Are memecoins halal? โ†’

An NFT is a certificate of ownership, so the ruling follows what it certifies. A token attached to genuine digital work or a usable licence can be a valid sale. It fails when the underlying content is prohibited, when the token grants nothing definable, which is gharar, or when the only reason to buy is to sell it to a greater fool.

Gharar explained โ†’

Privacy is not prohibited in Islam, and keeping your finances away from strangers is normal and permissible. The concerns raised about privacy coins are mostly about how third parties use them and about regulatory status in your country, which is a legality question rather than a fiqh one.

Are privacy coins halal? โ†’

A governance token gives you a vote over a protocol, so the ruling follows the protocol you would be governing. Voting rights over a decentralised exchange that settles spot trades is a very different thing from voting rights over a lending market that sets interest rates.

Why the label decides little โ†’

Two tokens can track the same company with one passing and one failing, which is what makes this different from ordinary equity screening. You have to screen the company and then screen the wrapper, because some tokenized stocks give you a real claim on shares held in custody and others give you a synthetic exposure backed by a derivative.

What you actually own โ†’

Manipulation is a sin committed by the manipulator, and it does not automatically make the asset prohibited for you. What it does change is the gharar assessment, because a token where a handful of wallets can move the price at will is a token where you cannot reasonably know what you are buying into. Supply concentration is part of our screen for exactly this reason.

Our screening method โ†’

Zakat and purification

The gold nisab is 85 grams and the silver nisab is 595 grams, and they give very different thresholds at today's prices. Using silver sets a lower bar, which means more people owe zakat and more of it reaches the poor, and that is the position most contemporary scholars favour for cash and trade goods.

Zakat calculator โ†’

You purify the impermissible share, not the whole return. Take the percentage of the project's income that comes from prohibited sources and apply it to what you received, so a 3% impermissible share on a 100 dollar gain means 3 dollars goes out. Purification is also not a fix for an asset that fails outright.

How to purify non-compliant income โ†’

Exchanges and wallets

You can use a mixed exchange for the halal part of what it offers, in the same way you can buy bread from a shop that also sells things you avoid. Keep to spot, and switch off the products that put you in a prohibited contract. The exchange is not the ruling, the product you press is.

Is your crypto exchange halal? โ†’

Same principle as any large exchange. Buying and selling spot is fine, and the products to leave alone are the ones that pay you a yield on your balance or lend against your holdings. Turn off the earn features and read what your account is enrolled in by default.

Is your crypto exchange halal? โ†’

Yes, and it is one of the cleanest ways to buy, because both sides hand over their side in the same session. Watch for two things, an escrow that holds your funds and pays a yield, and price spreads so wide they stop being a sale and start being a fee for waiting.

Halal remittances without riba โ†’

Stocks and other assets

Owning a share means owning a piece of a real business, which is permissible in principle. It fails when the business itself is prohibited, such as a bank or a brewery, or when the company carries too much interest bearing debt. That second test is what stock screening exists to measure.

Screened stocks โ†’

Three thresholds do the work. Interest bearing debt must stay under 30% of market cap, interest bearing deposits and investments under 30%, and income from prohibited activities under 5% of total income. Passing all three still leaves you with a purification duty on that small impermissible share.

Screened stocks โ†’

An ETF is a basket, so the ruling depends on what is in it and how the fund is built. A physically backed fund tracking a screened index can pass, while a synthetic ETF that gets its exposure through a swap contract rather than owning the assets fails on the wrapper alone.

What you actually own โ†’

Gold is permissible to own, and the condition is that the exchange settles immediately, since gold is one of the six commodities the hadith names specifically. Physical gold and fully allocated accounts satisfy that. Gold CFDs and futures do not, because nothing is ever delivered.

Zakat calculator โ†’

Owning a share of a property and taking a share of the rent is a partnership, and that is permissible. Read carefully though, because many platforms are structured as loans to a developer with a fixed return, which is riba wearing a property label. Fixed return is the word to look for.

Riba in plain language โ†’

A bond is a loan and the coupon is interest, which is why bonds are out. A sukuk is meant to give you ownership of an underlying asset and a share of what that asset earns, so your return rises and falls with it. Some sukuk in the market are structured to behave like bonds, so the label alone is not enough.

Riba in plain language โ†’

Learning to trade

Market structure is the sequence of highs and lows that tells you whether a market is trending up, trending down or going sideways. You read it on the higher timeframe first and then work down, because a buy that looks good on the 15 minute chart often looks reckless on the daily.

Trend and timeframes โ†’

Yes, and there is nothing in fiqh that discourages it, since protecting your wealth is an obligation rather than a lack of tawakkul. A stop is just an instruction to sell your own property at a price you chose in advance, when you were calm.

Spot-only risk rules โ†’

Position sizing and impatience, far more often than bad analysis. People risk too much on one idea, then double down to recover, then abandon a rule they set for themselves the previous week. Muslim traders carry an extra version of this, taking a haram shortcut after a run of losses and calling it necessity.

Why most Muslim traders lose money โ†’

Signals fail the people who follow them, and the reason is structural rather than dishonest. You receive an entry without the reasoning, so you cannot judge when the idea has been invalidated, and you exit late every time. Learn to read the chart yourself, even slowly.

Why crypto signals fail โ†’

Using ShariaQuant

We ask whether the asset is property at all, then run it through three layers covering the business activity, the tokenomics and the contract structure. One failure in any layer is enough to reject it. The whole method is published rather than kept behind a login.

Our screening method โ†’

The reasoning follows published rulings from recognised scholars and standards bodies, and every verdict page shows which principle it turned on so you can check the working. We publish the fatwas we rely on rather than asking you to take our word for it.

Scholar fatwas โ†’

Yes, when the project changes. A token that adds a lending market or alters its emission schedule can move from pass to fail, and that has happened. Screening a coin once and treating the answer as permanent is how people end up holding something that stopped being permissible.

The verdicts that surprised us โ†’

The screener, the verdicts, the glossary, the zakat calculator and every article are free. Paid plans add deeper analysis, the courses and mentorship. You do not need to pay anything to find out whether a coin passes.

Screen a coin โ†’

No. What we publish is Shariah screening and education, which tells you whether an asset is permissible, not whether it is a good buy at today's price. Those are different questions and only you can answer the second one for your situation.

Disclaimer โ†’

Most communities give you either the fiqh or the charts, and you are left to reconcile the two yourself. We screen the asset first, then teach a spot-only method for trading what survives that screening, and the reasoning behind both is published rather than sold as a signal. If a coin fails, we say so even when it is the one everybody wants to buy.

See the courses โ†’

Spot ownership only, on assets that have already passed screening. No margin, no futures, no perpetuals, and no positions in meme tokens whose only source of return is the next buyer. That removes riba from the financing side and maysir from the position itself, which are the two failures that catch most retail traders.

Spot vs derivatives โ†’

Open threads

Questions members asked that the team is answering in public. Every thread becomes a page other Muslims can find.

No open threads right now. Ask the first one with the button at the top.

Prefer to talk it through? The community is on WhatsApp and every other platform.